Site Update – October 9, 2026: We've added a new Wanted & Trade section to Indiana Bottle Collectors! This page features Indiana bottles and other bottling-related items we're looking to purchase or have available for trade. Other users may also submit items for consideration, and all submissions will be reviewed before being approved for listing. We're also continuing to expand the site with new sections for Beer & Soda Bottles, Milk Bottles, and other Indiana bottling-related categories. The Explore Counties page is currently down while we work on something new that will be simpler and easier to navigate. More updates are coming soon! Have an Indiana bottle or historical information to share? Please visit our User Submission page.

Magic City Ice Cream Company

  • County: Lake County
  • Location: Gary
  • Years Active in the Business: c. 1908 — 1936

The Vidette-Messenger of Porter County published an article on October 12, 1933, stating that the Magic City Ice Cream Co. was established in 1908 by Charles Atkins. It’s listed in the 1909 Gary phone book.

The 1911 Gary city directory shows the business at 471 Washington Street. It is listed at 457 Washington Street in 1935. By 1937, it appears as the Atkins Ice Cream Co. at 457 Washington Street.

Gary was called the “Magic City” because it seemed to rise out of nowhere after U.S. Steel arrived in 1906. In just a few years, dunes and open land turned into a booming, company-built city. Gary was incorporated on July 14, 1906.

If you have anymore on this one, please share it with us.

Bottle Photos

#1

Bottle Type: Pint milk
Embossing: MAGIC CITY / ICE CREAM CO / PHONE 569 / GARY, IND. 
Glass Maker: T.M.C. (embossed above front heel), Thatcher. 
Other Marks: 11 (embossed on front heel), 22 (embossed on base). 
Notes: 
Photo Credit: Indiana Bottle Collectors

View Full-Size Image

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *